Nov 7, 2007 8:39pm
Re: studio better than live?
I have to say, imo the 2 minute DS mops the floor with most live versions.
Referring of course, to the 18th take (unreleased), not what's on the archive or single.
I love the Live Dead version (gorgeous 16 track seperation), but I couldn't sit through it or any of the other long versions (I've heard) again unless I was a captive audience.
Like on a 2+ hour long bus ride.
Or while under the influence.
Other studio preferences (though I dig live too):
Cream Puff War (the uncut, extended, remastered version)
(on the other hand, Viola Lee was far better live than on the 1st lp. Cold Rain And Snow is one of the better 1st lp tracks, but was better live, for a while.
I agree that BIODTL was better on the lp).
And So We Leave The Castle
Mountains Of The Moon (that mix and the harpsichord gets me)
Doin That Rag (the original mix of Aoxomoxoa)
Dire Wolf (well...)
Til The Morning Comes
Attics Of My Live (but tell me your favorite live version - with vocals as in key as the lp version)
Unbroken Chain (I like the studio effects)
This post was modified by cream-puff-war on 2007-11-08 04:39:03